It is totally unfair that in Malaysia, the majority of parents are stuck with a crappy education system due to the Government’s political agendas. When I was in school, being in a Government School was still OK as the syllabus then was a tweak from the British curriculum but over the years, it has only deteriorated to the dogs. My youngest brother’s generation do not speak good English. At all. And now they’re just learning all sorts of unnecessary crazy stuff at school.
So when it came to our turn to decide on a school, it was a no-brainer exactly what we wanted for our child:-
A good syllabus (meaning the child learns useful things, not how great a certain religion is),
Good teachers (so the child never loses his love for learning),
Good School Culture (we knew what we wanted, somewhere where students were polite)
Balanced Demographics (we didn’t want our kid to be hanging out with a big group of High Society cliques)
Decent Facilities (to us, as long as it was clean and decent, we weren’t fussed)
Good Location (this played a major part in our decisions as I am already stretched with time as it is, and no, I cannot afford a driver nor do I want my kid picked up from school by a driver)
Affordable Price (how many people can afford a true international school???)
The Hubs and I have very different views on schooling. He had gone to a Chinese School for his first few Primary years and then International School in Singapore for the rest of it whilst I had attended a Government School for my first few years at Primary and then a local Private School for the rest of it. The Hubs was dead set AGAINST sending our kids to a Chinese School or a Government School because he hated Chinese School. He said that the start of his learning life with Chinese School had killed his enthusiasm to learn or ask any questions and this kept him always in the background without a voice. Even if you had the spirit, he felt that eventually a Chinese School would dampen it unnecessarily and you would only start bullying your own children to do things out of fear if you were a product of Chinese School yourself. It’s the only way you know! I refuted that claim because to me, education starts at home and if you were hands on with your kids, they would thrive in any environment. I guess it also boils down to your child’s personality and whether they are strong enough to adapt or not. We also hate the caning, punishment and demoralisation of kids that goes on in some of the Chinese Schools…….
The Hubs didn’t want our kids going to a Government School because he’s seen current products of Government School kids but to be fair, it also depends on which Government School they come from and how involved the parents are in the lives of these kids. I know of kids in Government Schools where a teacher could be absent for days and the kids are just left to their own devices to play all day in class without a teacher to monitor them. I also know of child molesters who are teachers in Government Schools. Of course, this can happen anywhere but the one I know of was from a Government School and this shows how stringent the system is in their selection of teachers. Not only is the syllabus crap, chances are majority of the teachers are crap as well. It is because the education system is run like a Government Service. If a teacher does not do his job, he still gets his wages so why should he do extra? And for the pittance that he makes as a teacher, really why should he do extra? He doesn’t even have to do extra…..even if he didn’t do the bare minimum, he would still get paid. I do qualify though that there are some very good teachers at Government Schools but you really need to know where they are. They are so trodden on and given so little credit for all that they do but it is them, who do this out of a true passion. If only there were more teachers like them.
After ruling out the Chinese School and the Government School systems, we were left with the local private option and going international. We initially did not want to go international because we felt that at such a young, impressionable age, we wanted our kids to stay local. We wanted them to learn about Malaysia (and the language), we wanted them to have a form of discipline and respect and we wanted them to have fantastic manners, something you just somehow get more of in a local school rather than an international school. Besides, international schools were expensive!
So we sent her to a local private school and she thrived very well for the first 2 years. For her 3rd year, the school announced that it was turning international due to the Government’s flip-flop nature in teaching Math and Science in Bahasa one day and in English the next. We parents had to make the decision to either place our kids in the international syllabus of a local private school, or leave the school completely. There was an option to remain in the local syllabus but we would have to move to another school location and as you can see above, location was one of the high priority factors in our decision making. So we opted to move T1 into the international syllabus and doubled our school fees. We felt it was a win-win situation with having a good solid educational syllabus (being the British) yet still being in a local environment (with the good value system).
For the first 3.5 months, T1 absolutely loved school. She has always loved school but now, she loved it even more. There was never a day when I’d ask her to skive (for my own convenience) when she would agree. My suggestions to skive always came with wild protests that she eventually won. When I learnt of her new set of British teachers at school, I was well impressed. Their entire approach to learning and teaching was a refreshing change to the local way of what we were used to. Somehow, the British expat teachers had a way of making the lessons super DUPER fun. Somehow they had a way of making the class LOVE History, LOVE English, LOVE Geography, LOVE Speech & Drama and LOVE school; which is all they taught. If only they taught Math, I can bet T1 would love Math too. That’s not to say teachers not from England cannot have the same approach! For example, T1’s Science teacher is Indian, but because of the teacher’s personality, she loves Science too. I could tell from T1’s stories every day that the money I paid for International School was worth it. I could tell from the private blog of the teachers and T1’s class that the kids were all LOVING school and LOVING the art of learning. I had never had such a curious T1. Sure, naturally as a child, she already had a million questions, but now that she LOVED school, she asked even more. Questions that mostly I couldn’t answer but instinctively became curious to find out as well! What an amazing dynamics it was!
Then T1’s British teachers announced that they were leaving due to unfortunate and unforeseen circumstances. I was crushed. They have left now and the class is in mourning. I am depressed because I don’t know if the new teachers that the school employs will have the same effect as that magical duo.
So now we are left with more decision making. To stay and pay obscene amounts for possibly sub-standard teachers? To move to a full-on entirely expat international school and pay even more obscene amounts of money (but possibly worth it? I don’t know. Everyone has their own views on it). Or to homeschool and quit my job? Or homeschool and work part time only, then hire a part-time tutor. We shouldn’t have to go through this.
A GREAT education should be FREE FOR ALL!!!
**************************************************************************
Who is Mamapumpkin?
Mamapumpkin is a former Design Architect turned Multi-Million Dollar Digital Entrepreneur. She sets out to prove to all that you can have anything and everything that you want; if you have that fire of desire burning within and the drive to work hard. Even better with much love.
Mamapumpkin has not only grown corporate businesses successfully in the past and doubled her salary 5 times over 5 organisations but has grown THREE BUSINESSES to 7 FIGURES within an 8 year period. She now shows others EXACTLY HOW after retiring her own husband from employment. He is now the official dog walker, family driver, chef and THE BEST FATHER to their two girls and THE BEST HUSBAND to the woman who CHOSE HIM!
Mamapumpkin is the girl who has nothing but fights for everything including YOU. She is idealistic in her desire to put unbelievable amounts of money and extrardinary happiness into the lives of good people so we can change the world together believing in happiness for ALL. She strives to impact lives authentically wanting to reduce poverty cycles and enable quality education for all and always supports the voiceless. She believes we can all have a life of our own desires to enable real contribution into the world. But first, one needs to understand what this all means.
A beautiful life without limits.
If you wish to learn how to propel your life forward guaranteed, be brave to take action. Mamapumpkin's purpose is to build people. Her gift is to help them UNCOVER their HIDDEN GIFTS. She operates fairly and always leaves an impression. You either love her or not and she is alright either way.
She is a living testimony that women really can have a lot. Being financially and time free has enabled her to travel the world anytime, anywhere, doing anything with anyone, as she spends most of her days with her children, having fun, supporting others wherever she can. Also having fun.
Hmmm. We’re going to be in a dilemma when we come back for good. 🙁
My son is also reaching the schooling age. We are in Shanghai, so we will have no choice but to choose between bilingual or international school (which provides Chinese education too). We are looking at several schools now but top in our criterea list are 1st: location, 2nd: english native speaking teachers 3rd: School mission
Hope you will have things sorted out soon…
It’s always such a dillema isn’t it? 🙂 I’m already scouting around and my little one’s only 3 – actually I’ve been scouting around since the day she was born, but starting to enrol this july! I am enrolling her in the school that moved from dheights to cheras, the chinese school off fed highway and the local primary school to cover all bases. That should give me another 2+ years to think some more about it 🙂
But my thoughts on the matter echo yours – I think it’s the input the parents give that mould the child the most. Even after placing my little one in a great preschool, I actually see the most results only after I drill her myself on the stuff she’s learnt in school.
how’s da methodist sch quality now? if the school is good and is a bit far from home..why not?
i will only worry and think about it a year b4 my son goes to sec school. cant think and decide now as things might change when the time comes. headache…
So what did you decide?
We moved back to KL from the US a year ago and the kids are at an international school. They love it. Every semester, we hand over our pound of flesh in payment. We don’t love that.
But, as you say, the alternatives are not great…
I’m also researching school options for my son who’s turning 5 next year. I thought we had it all figured (after much flip flopping between public chinese and private / intl schools) but now it’s back to the drawing board. How do you find the school T1 is in? I’ll be visitng the school but would like to hear first hand feedback from parents.
Hi, my girl is starting her grade 3 next week in ISKL, after spending 3 years in a local chinese school we are finally made up our mind to send her to international school. The main reason for us sending her to a local school is that she can be bilingual. I think we have achived what we aim for so we moved her to a better school now.
Hi mommies out there
I will be moving to KL next year, and i am in a dilemma as to what schools to register for my child who will be 5 next year.
I prefer private schools but worried about the fees and some may not be as good as they claimed to me.
Please give me some comments, and are Chinese schools all academic based?
Totally agree on education not having a price tag, good article and topic!
Thank you for the insight. We are waiting for admissions exams (for reception year, British syllabus). Do you know if it will be tough? What do they look for in a 4 year old going on 5, other than the obvious scholarly virtues of which my little one has yet to possess?
Hope to hear your views!
Common, You must be a board of directors from HELP Int. Like u said, the school just opened… So, it has lots of teething issues… till at this stage the pool is not open for use, the caterers are pretty useless and parents are forever comparing it with Tenby or Kinsley as most immigrated over from there…If you want to compare, compare it with the best, not with cap shit holes. I am not saying it is a bad school. It will be a good school…maybe in 3 – 5years time …. For now really lots of teething issues…
Am I the only one who has not realized the name of the school? Appreciate if you can inform me, thanks.
I think good teachers make or break a school. Good management attracts good teachers. Thus, it is important to know what kind of leadership is in place at the school.
I have experienced that our good local teachers can easily outperform expatriate teachers across multiple areas for comparisons- thus it is not a matter of nationality as mentioned. However, due to wage structures, good local teachers are forced to teach at the higher levels to make ends meet, thus MamaPumpkin may have had a comparison of specialised expat teachers (at lower levels) vs second-grade local teachers.]
Expat teachers can also be quite a ‘performer’, acting in the classrooms and with parents. Due to our post-colonial thinking, we lap it up enthusiastically giving them the benefit of the doubt. Malaysian teachers bring with them a high work ethic, good respectful values, honest realisation of their limitations and a desire to share with the parents (the good and the bad) about their kids (as oppose to painting a rosy picture only).
So, when judging a school- the list that MamaPumpkin showed was quite good. But note that teachers are not to be adjudged by the colour of their skin.